Sunday, November 18, 2012

Self-Determination of Political structure, Leadership and Clan Politics

A high level delegation consisting of Somali and African Union Mission in Somalia, AMISOM, officials were denied access to Kismayo, Lower Jubba region, about two weeks ago.

No prior arrangement was made by the delegation with Somali and AMISOM officials in the region; it for this reason that they were denied acces to the town, as claimed by Kenyan minister of Tourism speaking to BBC Somali Service and Abdinasir Serar, speaker of a temporary administration of Kismayo city, speaking also to VOA Somali service.

All parties, the federal government and local actors, agree on application of the principle of self-determination: let the people who live in the relevant regions determine their political fate. The president of Somalia has confirmed his acceptance on the principle of self-determination in a press conference, held after being in office for 61 days.

Some people in the region have already made up their mind, though; they want to build a state known as Jubbaland state, consisting of Lower Jubba, Middle Jubba and Gedo.

Raskamboni militia, a militia allied to the federal government, but not part of it, as well as federal government, FG,  army in lower Jubba region, support Jubbaland state.  Mohamed Farah, spokesperson of the FG army in Jubba provinces has confirmed this position to the VOA Somali service, two weeks ago.

Raskamboni militia spokesperson Abdinasir Seerar has confirmed to the VOA Somali Service, on November 10, 2012, the ongoing efforts in Kismayo, both by Somalis and Non-Somalis, to form new state consisting of Jubba provinces and Gedo.

Most Darod communities, even those in Puntland state of Somalia, as confirmed by press statement produced by civil society members in Puntland, circulated in Somali sites, support the proposed state of Jubbaland. Puntland government also officially supports Jubbaland project.

The reason why Darod communities support this proposed state is not difficult to apprehend: edition of Gedo to Jubba regions strengthens the power position of Darod communities in Jubba provinces.

To see this point, add Lower Shabelle to Jubba regions, instead of Gedo, a predominantly Darod province, even though other clans live there, such as Dir and Digil & Mirifle; if you do this, you will strengthen the power position of Dir clans, as well as Hawiye and Digil Mirifle clans to some extent, simultaneously it will reduce, relatively,  the power position of Darod communities in Jubba provinces.

Some sites have reported an ongoing conference in Mogadishu this week, mid of November, envisioning different structure of some provinces in southern Somalia, including some of those in the proposed state of Jubbaland.

Jubbaland state, however, is favored by Kenya, whose troops constitute the bulk of the forces in Jubba provinces, for it wishes, as indicated  to create a buffer zone between itself and endless civil wars of Somalia.

Shebab, according to UN, had received up to $50 million dollars annually from this region. So, both money and power is behind the political wrangling of Jubba provinces.

The solution to this problem is simple; let the people in the region decide both the structure of their political dispensation and the leadership of their region. Impose not on them either structure, e.g. Jubbaland, or leadership from elsewhere, e.g. from Mogadishu.

They can do this by following the model of how the federal government was created in Mogadishu this year, 2012: elders, technical committees, parliament, president and so on. Eventually, however, residents of these regions will decide through voting their political structure and leadership. The former dispensation will be temporary, the latter permanent.


No comments:

Post a Comment